mariahelenaji

  • Hair: Dry
  • Skin Type: Oily
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

The product is great! It lasts very long. In fact, it lasted more than 24 hours. I had already replaced my old eyeliner with this amazing product. The brush is also very easy to control. The gel is semisolid which made the product very easy to spread on the eyes but at the same time it does not smudge. I recommended it to my friends who are used to liquid eyeliners.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

enlvalencia

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Sensitive
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I liked this product, and would definitely consider buying it again. I typically prefer using pen type eyeliners with brush tips, and so this turned out necessitating an extra step for me that I'm not so used to, and I'm still not sure if I am okay with -- largely because it takes me a bit longer to apply, and I don't like spending a lot of time on my makeup. Having said that, the product was a pleasure to use and had great staying power. The main qualm I have about it is that it has a tendency to smudge. I've adjusted to that by using it for smoky eye makeup rather than just lining, but this look/application may not work for everyone.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

dutchfairyph

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

Finally, I found the perfect gel liner. This product is super easy to use and it creates the perfect winged liner that I like. The consistency of the gel is just right, it is not that moist and it is easy to dry. The brush included is nice too. The gel liner does not smudge and it lasted on me for 6 hours. I will definitely buy this again.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Abbythoughts

  • Hair: Oily
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

This one from Cathy doll is really good. The gel liner doesn't smudge and has a good staying power. My eyelids are a bit droopy and i am usually having a hard time drawing lines with my eyeliners, but this one did great. It's easy to use even for beginners. Plus, the price is reasonable!

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

jhoheart74

  • Hair: Oily
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

It doesn't last long on my oily eye lids. The brush is okay but it's hard to use it to draw a cat eye. I like that it opens up my eyes because of the strong black color. this is okay for beginners on makeup

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

ann070588

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Normal
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

At first, I was a bit hesitant to try it because I am not good at applying make up. Surprisingly, it didn't give me a hard time applying it. It looks great, last long and easier to draw than other gel liner and gives life to my eyes.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

ella_girl

  • Hair: Normal
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Medium
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

Originally wanted to try the compact but since I didn't have enough points, I settled for the liner. I didn't regret it though because I really like this product. It complements my eyelash extension. It rounds up and gives my eyes a natural 'wide awake' look. I need not spend a lot of time fixing the rest of my mug because my peepers take center stage. The only peeve I have is that during humid weather, it spreads to my lower lashes giving me a mild panda look. And due to its long lasting quality, I have a hard time removing it.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

cheannTL

  • Hair: Normal
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I have oily skin so the product did not last very long (around 4 hours or less). I also had to close my eyes for a few minutes to ensure that it does not smudge. I wasn't used to using brush tips for eye liners so the 1st time I tried it, I failed horribly but got used to it eventually. I also felt that the color wan't black enough (if there is such a thing). Will probably stick to my old liner.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

lisa

  • Hair: Normal
  • Skin Type: Normal
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

Packaging is nice. The brush has its own compartment and is not "soaked" in the gel all the time. The brush's diameter though is a little too thick for my taste. I like my black eyeliner to be reeeeeally really fine and thin. But this is gel liner, not liquid, so maybe it's meant to be used for thicker eye lines. Longevity is awesome. It has to be taken off with makeup remover or a really long, hot shower. Overall verdict,well, it's still in my make up bag!

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

bavedc

  • Hair: Normal
  • Skin Type: Normal
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

My first gel liner in my stash. It takes practice to perfect the application. But it is beginner friendly. A small amount goes a long way, be careful though it dries fast. Doesnt smudge even I accidentally scratch my eyes. Not heavy on the skin. I will buy another once I finish this bottle.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

leasamimee2

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Dry
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I love the packaging, it's kinda cute and it applies smoothly. The only thing is this gel liner smudged and not that pigmented. When I napped one afternoon I looked like panda when I woke up.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

tin2123

  • Hair: Dry
  • Skin Type: Oily
  • Skin Tone: Medium
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I'm not really a fan of gel liners with this packaging and I don't think this product changes that. It doesn't go on as smooth (like pencil gel liners) and is a bit messy to apply. Plus, I have really, really oily lids so it doesn't last that long. However, I do like the pigmentation. It's not super black as expected but somehow, I'm drawn to it.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

nesrine

  • Hair: Dry
  • Skin Type: Oily
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I am not a fan of wearing eye liner because I find it hard to make a perfect eye make up. But this gel liner convinced me that it is easy. It is so easy to use and is so handy. I got the perfect line after two tries only compared to other lines that I needed to do it more than 5 times. The gel liner is so easy to control and gives a perfect eye makeup with less effort. It dries a bit fast but I can always use cotton buds to create a cleaner look. One of the reason why I got this sample is the packaging.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

shinypinklips

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I love the consistency of this product. Very easy to glide, nice brush, very compact and the packaging is sturdy. I love how black it is, not shiny and not too matte, just in between. I didn't experience allergic reactions, or itchiness, for the price it's really a good product. However, it smudges, nothing I hate more than panda eyes and sadly, for my skin tone, it sorts of metls.. I don't know why. Pretty sure it would work for others.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

alviclemente

  • Hair: Dry
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

When purchasing eye liner, I usually go for the pencil or liquid liner ever since I started experimenting with make-up. Although I usually see the pot liners on Korean make-up stalls, I never tried it, until today. And the experience? Boy, I'm inlove! I am sure I'd be purchasing another pot of Cathy Doll Geisha Moteru Gel Liner after I have my pot emptied. It is so easy to apply. Sometimes, I not only use it as a liner, it could also double as an eyeshadow as well cos when i smudge it, it brings a really cool smokey-eyed look. Two thumbs up!

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Azedur

  • Hair: Normal
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Medium
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I’ve used this eyeliner for a good week or so. I love how easy it is to use the brush and the overall application is really smooth. I just feel that the formula is too thick for my liking. It’s not the most matte and the blackest eyeliner in the market. Also, it takes a little while before it dries up completely. I have to say it is long wearing and does not smudge. Good effort but not the best gel liner I’ve tried.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

girlieloulielou

  • Hair: Normal
  • Skin Type: Oily
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

My putting on makeup skills is pretty bad but thanks to the brush included I could easily draw eye line than I expected. I still need to learn how to do it better though to maximize exquisite result of any eye liner. It lasts long and I usually don't need to reapply.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

sugarandspice

  • Hair: Normal
  • Skin Type: Normal
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I had high hopes for the Cathy Doll Geisha Moteru Gel Liner Pot (Black). The packaging is very sleek and classy. It claims (long lasting and water proof) probably doesn't apply to someone who has oily face like me. I have to wait a few minutes after application because it doesn't dry up easily. I get smudges on the side of my eye after just a few hours especially when not in an airconditioned place. It's price though is very affordable.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

chili720

  • Hair: Oily
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I just love this gel liner! The brush that comes with the liner makes it very easy to draw. The consistency of the gel is great too and opaque. It leaves a nice matte finish. Definitely long lasting since I was able to use it for more than 6 hours without any fading. It really makes your eye makeup more exquisite and defined.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Lhenie

  • Hair: Oily
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

The Cathy Doll Gel liner is drier than most gel liners I've tried and because of this I find it hard to apply especially with the brush it came with. It takes around 5 minutes to dry and there are times that it transfers to my under eye. It only lasts for around 4 hours. I like that the shade is matte black and it looks good for everyday wear but it might need a primer first to make it more long lasting

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe