trina3ns

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

My crybaby days with eyeliners are over. Thanks to this product! This can last the whole day on my eyes even if I already washed my face or accidentally rub my eyes hours after application. It is so easy to use and its packaging is classy. The brush and pot combo is very unique and I like it that way because it's lightweight and not messy to use. If there's a brown shade for this. I would definitely buy it for a softer and younger look for my eyes.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

cayl907

  • Hair: Dry
  • Skin Type: Normal
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

First time to use a gel liner, and it was beyond what I expected. It's so easy to use and very convenient. The gel also stayed on for a longer time. The only downside is the smudging after a few hours that is why I'm giving this a 4 instead of a 5.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

thea0021

  • Hair: Oily
  • Skin Type: Oily
  • Skin Tone: Medium
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I have monolids, so finding a smudge proof eye liner without using an eye primer is really hard for me. I've tried everything from high-end to drug store make up, but still nothing passed my expectations (price, quality and efficacy). Yesterday, I used the Cathy Doll geisha gel liner, it was easy to apply and there was no chemical scent. It does glide at application. I wear it without an eye primer and it lasted for 3 hours with minimal smudge without looking like a Panda, so using a primer would be best. I would say this will be my everyday liner very practical with the price. I must say I am impressed with the quality and efficacy. Korean products are simply my bet.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

jennyjive

  • Hair: Dry
  • Skin Type: Sensitive
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I'm not really a fan of gel liners but I thought of giving this Cathy Doll gel liner a chance just to see if I could actually end up liking it or not. Unfortunately, I didn't like it at all. The applicator was a bit difficult to use because even if you attach it to the cover, it still didn't feel comfortable to use and it also kept moving a lot - it doesn't attach well to the cover - so it was hard to keep a steady hand. The gel isn't pigmented as well so I had to dip the brush several times in the pot. I also experienced some fall-outs especially a few minutes after application. I didn't even like how my eyes looked after finishing the application so I had to fix it using an eye pencil just to make it look better. I don't see myself using this again.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Kittenish07

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

It's my first time to use a gel liner and I find this product nice with its black tint and brush to apply it which makes it easier for a first timer like me. However, it doesn't last that long, and just a simple touch on it and it smudge on your face.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

angeliya

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I am not an expert in gel lining my eyes and it was no different with this product. I think I just did not practice well enough to draw perfectly like how beauty guru's line their eyes in their beauty videos. I was lucky to at least line my eyes decently for several times. I think it is blackest black on my lids and they make my eyes look really beautiful. It is long lasting as well since I needed to use my eye make-up remover several times to remove it. It is a good eye liner product which I could use during the holidays (provided that I practice more to perfect my cat's eyes). I would recommend to my friends to buy.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

TeamOng

  • Hair: Dry
  • Skin Type: Normal
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I used to apply liquid liner. Using the gel is quite challenging & had to do trial and error to achieve the look that I want. I like that it stays longer & doesn't smudge. Maybe I need to try it more to be better at applying a gel based liner. I love the brand though. Thank you!

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

bebearz

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

This was my firstime to use a gel-type eyeliner, and I was amazed how easy to use this because of the brush that comes with it. Application is so easy because you can erase the smudge. At first, it looks great; almost perfect. But after hours of wearing this, it became a nightmare. It smudges all over and tiny black particles fall out especially on the lower lash line. So, it's not good. I wasn't impressed with this eyeliner.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

harumilani

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Oily
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

For a liner pot its color is really pigmented and it glides on the skin perfectly. It's also long lasting and you don't have to re-apply for the duration of the day. The brush will take some getting use to if you prefer fine lines when drawing on your eyes. I would buy one but I would use another brush for it.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Esoteric Vicenarian

  • Hair: Oily
  • Skin Type: Oily
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I didn't expect much from this product but I was so wrong. This has got to be one of the easiest gel liners to use. It's very creamy so it's easy to glide on the lids and it's jet back so you could have a great color pay off with just a few swipes. I also love the brush that came with it because the size is perfect for my lids. One thing that I can complain is that at the end of the day, it smudged on my lower lids but it's because I have very oily lids. Next time I'll use it with a better primer.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

samwisegamgee

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Natural
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I had high hopes for this product because the geisha name is a symbol for the famous Japanese look. Too bad it does not dry quickly and it transfers to my lids even after using a primer. I find the applicator difficult to navigate. The color is super black, but unfortunately I won't purchase because of the performance.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

frau31

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Dry
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I love the packaging and the unique brush is perfect for eye shaping. It doesn't dry easily as it comes in a gel form. It glides smoothly on my skin and it brings a nice perfect black shade for a more dramatic look. It lasts for 3- 5 hours for me. It is waterproof but I did not have a hard time removing it after the event.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Malou011

  • Hair: Normal
  • Skin Type: Sensitive
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I've been trying to figure out how this product works. I like eyeliners, and I thought that maybe I could try the gel liners, too! But sadly, if I wanted a super defined eyeliner, this product is not for me. Or maybe because it's my first time to try on gel liners and I had difficulty in applying it. (Maybe I should practice more. I am not giving up on this product!) But to be fair, it is long lasting for me. When I first tried it (and failed) I was at home so I didn't bother to remove it immediately. I also tried working with it to have a dark smokey eyes effect, it worked! So I think it's nice overall and that I just need to practice using it more often. :)

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Dru

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Oily
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I prefer gel liners because for me it's easier to apply. I love this because it doesn't smudge and it lasts a long time. It makes my eyes more noticeable and I love that it's also easy to remove at the end of the day.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Beijos

  • Hair: Dry
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

Uhm, no, it's not waterproof. :( While I loved how easy it was to draw on my eye line, and gave me absolutely stunning Cleopatra-eyes, it fell sort on the long-lasting department. I used this during my friend's wedding, and noticed smudging within an hour. After 3 hours, I had to redo my undereye area (full coverage from scratch--- foundation, concealer and finishing powder) because I looked like a panda already. :(

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Kmmanalilimd

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I personally don't use eye liners but when I tried this gel eye liner, it's really an amazing product for me. It is smudge free and definitely long lasting. This is a must buy product. Thumbs up!

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

mdmeileen

  • Hair: Normal
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I have VERY VERY OILY EYELIDS, and eyeliners are not my favorite makeup product because they all smudge on me even when I just applied it. However, I think I may have found my HOLY GRAIL EYELINER! It doesn't smudge on me at all! This is the most budget proof eyeliner out there! I have tried high end eyeliners and they don't compare a bit to this one! HIGHLY HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! WILL DEFINITELY REPURCHASE!

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

jehaniswhut

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Light
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

The color was sheer and it did not glide on smoothly. For gel eyeliners, I expected a very black, more opaque color payoff. When I applied it to my eyelids, the color was closer to light gray than black. Also, the applicator was not easy to use and the product was difficult to apply. Too bad, it seemed promising.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

Crown

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Oily
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

This gel liner is easy to use. A little goes a long way which makes it very economical. It is best for those who want to have a dramatic eye look. It's also long lasting. I can compare this brand's quality to other high end and very expensive brands so this makes it a dupe which is very nice.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe

jjtjcj

  • Hair: Colored and Chemically Treated
  • Skin Type: Combination
  • Skin Tone: Fair
Long Lasting
Easy to Draw
Exquisite Eye Makeup
Overall Experience

I usually just go out with a natural look so wearing black liner is not part of my usual routine everyday. I have oily lids and I love how this black liner didn't budge an inch which usually happens when I use eye liners. This is the selling factor for me. I am going to buy this for my friends who loves using eye liners and give it to them as a gift.

Will you buy this product again?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe